Chateau Score75.4The Francis House
10.0Exceptional9 reviews
- Pool
- Shuttle
Best forSpa / relaxed north-valley stays, Pool
Good to knowHas higher guest score, a smaller review base, a higher price band.
Calistoga / Resort
The Inn on Pine, Calistoga
The Inn on Pine has 386 reviews behind a 9.4 score, the strongest review base in our Calistoga selection. It has a pool and a terrace, sits 0.25 miles from the town center, and its price snapshot is in our mid-range band.
Photo from the property listing on Booking.com.
9.4Guest score
386Reviews
75.7Chateau Score
$$Price band
Hotel facts
- TownCalistoga
- Property typeResort
- Star rating3-star
- Guest score9.4 / 10
- Reviews386
- Review confidenceHigh
- Chateau Score75.7 / 100
- From Calistoga center0.25 mi
- WalkabilityHighly walkable
- To winery corridor11.91 mi
- Price band$$
- SpaNot listed
- PoolYes
- RestaurantNot listed
- BarNot listed
- TerraceYes
- Pets allowedNot listed
Guest score and review count checked August 2026. Features come from the current property data and are never inferred. "Not listed" means the source data does not record the feature, which is not the same as confirming its absence.
How this Chateau Score is built
- Guest rating quality (max 45)34.2
- Review confidence (max 20)19.2
- Location fit (max 15)15.0
- Stay features (max 10)3.3
- Category breadth (max 10)4.0
- Total75.7 / 100
The formula is identical for every property on this site and is published in full on our methodology page.
Why choose The Inn on Pine?
A 9.4 across 386 stays is the best-evidenced strong rating in Calistoga, and it comes with a pool and a walkable position at a mid-range price. In value terms nothing else in town in our selection matches that combination.
Location and what is nearby
The property is inside the Calistoga core and classified Highly walkable. It is 12.1 miles from our Highway 29 corridor reference point.
Who is this hotel best for?
- Travelers who want the best-evidenced rating in Calistoga
- Guests who want a pool at a mid-range price
- Couples who want to walk into town
Good to know
It is classified as a resort in the source data but has no spa, restaurant or bar, and it is a three-star property. There is no confirmed thermal or mineral-springs connection, so it does not appear in our hot springs selection.
Check current rates
Rates and availability change daily and we do not publish fixed nightly prices. Check live rates for your dates on Booking.com.
This is an affiliate link. It costs you nothing extra and it does not affect whether this hotel appears in our selections.
Alternatives to The Inn on Pine
Selected from properties with the closest overall profile, nearest town first. Each one differs from The Inn on Pine in a specific way.
Chateau Score75.4
Chateau Score77.4Brannan Cottage Inn
9.3Superb160 reviews
- Pet-friendly
- Restaurant
- Terrace
- Shuttle
Best forSpa / relaxed north-valley stays, Couples
Good to knowHas lower guest score, a smaller review base, a higher price band.
Chateau Score80.9Four Seasons Resort Napa Valley
9.6Exceptional31 reviews
- 5-star
- Spa
- Pool
- Pet-friendly
- Restaurant
Best forSpa / relaxed north-valley stays, Pool, Spa
Good to knowHas higher guest score, a smaller review base, a spa.
Where The Inn on Pine appears on this site
Frequently asked questions
Does The Inn on Pine have hot springs?
No geothermal or mineral-springs facility is confirmed in our sources. A pool is confirmed.
Which Calistoga hotel has the most reviews?
The Inn on Pine, with 386 reviews behind a 9.4 score.
Hotel data last reviewed August 23, 2026. Guest ratings, review counts and prices change over time. We publish the date so you can judge how current the figures are.